Alkali-aggregate-reaction (AAR)

Two problems arise dealing with alkali-aggregate-reaction (AAR) in structures: how to prevent damages in new structures and how to deal with structures that are already affected? Regarding the first issue, there are different ways in concrete production to prevent deleterious AAR in new structures. One is the use of non-reactive aggregates. However, a concrete producer often has no access to such aggregates either due to regional unavailability or financial reasons. The other one is to reduce the alkalinity of the pore solution in concrete to a level where no deleterious AAR occurs with the aggregate used. This can be achieved by the use of suitable mineral admixtures mitigating AAR or of cement with low Na2O-equivalent.

Molar K/Na ratio in pore solution compared to gel composition in concrete.

It has been shown repeatedly that the expansion in mortar or concrete produced with low alkali cement is lower in comparison to high alkali cement. Consequently, various national guidelines and standards take measures to reduce the content of soluble alkalis in concrete by limiting the Na2O-equivalent of the cement or by limiting the cement content. However, the Na2O-equivalent may not always be a reliable parameter defining the potential of cement to cause AAR. Firstly, the alkalis in cement can either be present as potassium and sodium sulfate or be bound in silicate and aluminate phases. Depending on the amount present in the different mineral phases the solubility during the first stage of hydration is different; potassium and sodium sulfate being the more soluble compounds. Secondly, the ratio of potassium to sodium can vary in different cements with consequences for the total amount of K2O and Na2O present. Thirdly, the Na2O-equivalent implies that the effect of potassium and sodium is equivalent. However, there are numerous studies indicating that the influence of potassium and sodium on silica and quartz dissolution is not identical.

Cracked aggregate with gel formation (BSE image).
The understanding of the detailed reaction mechanisms is essential to successfully prevent AAR in new structures. Therefore, we study the interaction between pore solution chemistry, reaction products and the connection to the resulting expansion. The results can help to deal with the second issue mentioned at the beginning: structures already damaged by AAR. At the moment, we evaluate ways to efficiently diagnose AAR and to explore the possibilities for a prognosis of future damages.
Important publications and documents on AAR

Leemann, A./Loser, R. Accelerated sulfate resistance test for concrete – chemical and mircrostructural aspects. The 2nd International Conference on Microstructural-related Durability of Cementitious Composites Amsterdam, The Netherlands, April 11-13, 2012

Leemann, A./Loser, R. Analysis of concrete in a vertical ventilation shaft exposed to sulfate-containing groundwater for 45 years. Cement & concrete composites 2011, 74–83
Leemann, L./Lothenbach, B./Siegrist, H./Hoffmann, C. Influence of water hardness on concrete surface deterioration caused by nitrifying biofilms in wastewater treatment plants. International Biodeterioration & Biodegradation 64 (2010) 489 - 498
Leemann, A./Lothenbach, B. The influence of potassium-sodium ratio in cement on concrete expansion due to alkali-aggregate reaction. Cement and Concrete Research 2008, 38(10), 1162-1168. /SCI
Leemann, A./Hammerschlag, J. G./Thalmann, C. Inconsistencies between different accelerated test methods used to assess alkali-aggregate reactivity. 13th International Conference on Alkali-Aggregate Reaction in Concrete, Trondheim, Norwegen, June 16-20, 2008, 10 pp. /CP
Leemann, A./Lothenbach, B./Thalmann, C. Betonexpansion durch eine Alkali-Aggregat-Reaktion. Der Bauingenieur 2008, 2008(4), 48-56. /NR
Leemann, A./Holzer, L. Alkali-aggregate reaction - identifying reactive silicates in complex aggregates by ESEM observation of dissolution features. Cement & concrete composites 2005, 27/ISI_SciCi_Ext
Leemann, A. Cemsuisse Fachtagung, 16.11.2005: Wie sieht AAR am Bauwerk aus?