Skip to Content

Particulate matter

Braking dust

Jan 26, 2021 | RAINER KLOSE

The broad introduction of particle filters reduced the emission of combustion generated fine and ultrafine particles significantly. As a result, brake disc and tire abrasion are moving into the focus of public health experts and engineers, given their health harming potential. There is still a major challenge, though: How can the quantity and size of brake dust particles be measured correctly? Empa researchers are currently developing a sophisticated method.

/documents/56164/14692031/Bremsstaub_stopper.jpg/2345ca3f-bb72-4e14-8daa-da5d5637a782?t=1602245711383
Particulate matter source: The brakes of a car emit particles of metal oxide. Image: Empa

The VW Jetta Hybrid on the chassis dynamometer in Empa's Automotive Powertrains Technologies Laboratory had a couple of years of duty as a fleet vehicle. Strapped into the test chamber, it has been part of a new research purpose since July 2020: The goal is to generate brake dust, strictly following the standardized WLTP driving cycle, is the cycle that is also used to determine exhaust emissions.

The interest in brake dust measurements is fairly recent: In June 2016, a department of the UN Economic Commission for Europe (UNECE) known as the "Particle Measurement Programme Informal Working Group" (PMP IWG) decided that it was time to develop a generally applicable test procedure for brake dust that would reliably determine the mass and the number of the emitted particles. Since then, a number of research institutions, vehicle manufacturers and specialized companies for testing equipment have addressed the topic. However, there some severe challenges to tackle.

Thrown in all directions
/documents/56164/14692031/EMPA_BremsstaubAuswahl-7747-web.jpg/c1f7eda8-fc9f-4489-b389-10abb5f84d5e?t=1611654552840
Research as close to real-life-conditions as possible. Image: Empa

Unlike an exhaust pipe, which reliably emits gases in a given direction, a rotating brake disc distributes the particles in all possible directions. So you first have to collect  the particles and then introduce them in a well-defined flow towards a particle analyzer. During this process losses have to be minimized: Neither fine particles should be escape, nor should coarse particles remain in the pipes.

Two further complications arise: The brakes of a vehicle  are attached to a rotating drive shaft, which must be carefully sealed for the measurement so that no particles are lost. In parallel a brakes have t be cooled. On the road, the airstream together with ventilation lamellas inside the brake disks provide a cooling breeze. A fully enclosed brake on a test bench, by contrast, can heat up quickly – and would then yield completely different particles than in real everyday traffic. Such an analysis would thus be of little value.

Measure all emissions at the same time
/documents/56164/14692031/Bremsstaub_para2.jpg/304817df-075d-49e7-9b67-5c17f8f1c0f5?t=1602245708097
Brake particles are collected by the 13-stage cascade impactor. Image: Empa

The UNECE's PMP IWG working group solves the problem by simplification: The desired brake tests are to be carried-out in completely enclosed test stands. Such test stands exist. They resemble large cabinets, in which brake discs and brake pads rub against each other. Only one component is tested, not the entire car.

"We are going to try out another way," says Panayotis Dimopoulos Eggenschwiler, who is designing the test setup at Empa. "We want to measure all emissions of a vehicle simultaneously during a test drive on the chassis dynamometer. This is much more meaningful than data from an isolated brake tester, which must then be converted to real-world conditions".

An airy bearing targeted design
/documents/56164/14692031/EMPA_BremsstaubAuswahl-7988-web.jpg/e9d28842-2bbc-4770-a7a9-692260cbde62?t=1611654554713
Empa engineer Daniel Schreiber in the Automotive Powertrain Technology lab. Image: Empa

Together with Daniel Schreiber, an engineer by training, Dimopoulos Eggenschwiler has developed the Empa version of the test, the results of which must now stand up to comparison with other international research teams. At Empa an entire vehicle is being tested, the VW Jetta Hybrid mentioned above. The brake of the right front wheel was enclosed in a specially designed metal housing. A compressed air pipe conveys large quantities of cooling air into the metal casing from the front end of the car; at the same time the air serves as the transport medium for the emitted brake particles. These are directed into a tube about along the vehicle. After a short flight time they land in a 13-stage cascade impactor, a special instrument that sorts particles according to size. Subsequently, the particle fractions can be chemically analyzed by weight. If necessary, their morphology and composition can also be examined using an electron microscope, for instance.

"In preliminary tests, we have already determined what of consisting elements of the brake particles," says Dimopoulos Eggenschwiler. "It is mainly iron oxide, which originates from the brake disc, and a number of further oxides and species containing aluminum, magnesium, calcium, potassium and titanium, which stem from the brake pads." In addition to coarse, particles, there are also smaller particles that can be inhaled and can enter the lungs.

Do hybrid vehicles brake differently?
/documents/56164/14692031/Bremsstaub_para4.jpg/b84214ef-088f-4ef5-b9d1-3e3d58c67d07?t=1602245710773
Particle fractions from the cascade impactor are sorted by size. Image: Empa

Now that the measuring process is running on a stable basis, the VW Jetta will initially be operated according to the legally prescribed WLTP cycle and will supply brake particles to the cascade impactor. Further test series are planed after that. "We want to find out, for example, whether hybrid vehicles brake differently compared to cars with conventional powertrain systems and hence result in different emissions," explains the project leader. Hybrid vehicles  are also capable of braking through their electric motor and, therefore, need to use their mechanical brakes much less frequently. On the other hand, hybrid vehicles have a higher mass. "With the results of our measurements, it will be possible to optimize the operating modes of future generation vehicles and keep brake dust emissions under better control than today".

This research is part of the research project "Particle Emissions from Brake Abrasion - Measurements and Analyses" and is financially supported by the Swiss Federal Office for the Environment (FOEN).


Editor / Media Contact


Follow us
            
Sustainable fuels

Volatile stuff for heavy trucks

In future, commercial vehicles will not only have to emit less CO2 but also meet stricter exhaust emission limits. Many experts expect that this could herald the end for fossil diesel. One possible alternative is dimethyl ether: The highly volatile substance burns very cleanly and can be produced from renewable energy. Empa is investigating this new powertrain concept using a special test engine. More. (Image: istock)

Noise reduction

A green earplug

Cars, trains, planes: For two thirds of the European population, traffic noise is part of everyday life. However, the right environment can have a major impact on this nuisance, as Empa researchers have found out. Green spaces in urban areas help to make road and railroad noise less of a nuisance. Only in the case of aircraft noise does this seem counterproductive: the greener the surroundings, the more disturbing the aircraft noise. More. (Image: Unsplash)

Radioactive waste repository

Modeling eternity in the rock laboratory

Cement is one of the key materials for the safe storage of radioactive waste. What is needed is an almost infinite durability of the containers. Empa researchers are therefore analyzing material systems that can handle this task. More. (Image: Pierre Montavon)

Quick Access

The latest EmpaQuarterly:
Focus: Energy revolution